Skip to content
Squalane Club

Paula's Choice Omega+ Complex Moisturizer: 4 Alternatives

The original is discontinued, so this is not a preference question - there is nothing left to re-buy. Four replacements, ranked on how much of the original they keep, and one thing none of them does.

By Stephen V.Last updated November 21, 2026
An open jar of face cream beside a dropper bottle on a warm neutral surface

We may earn a commission if you buy through our links, at no extra cost to you. Prices are pulled live from Amazon and can change. How this works.

The replacement is Paula's Choice RESIST Barrier Repair Advanced Moisturizer - from the brand that discontinued the original - for anyone who liked the Omega+ Complex because it was a fragrance-free barrier cream that left skin comfortable. The budget pick is The Ordinary 100% Plant-Derived Squalane, which is not a cream and costs a fraction of one, and is on this page because a large part of what the original did was put emollient lipids on your face. First, the fact that makes this page different from a comparison: the Omega+ Complex Moisturizer is discontinued. Paula's Choice stopped making it, we verified the listing as unavailable twice, and there is no live buy link to it anywhere on this site. You are not weighing it against these four. You are replacing it.

So the useful question is what exactly you are replacing, stated in ingredients rather than impressions. The Omega+ Complex was a fragrance-free cream built on squalane, omega-3, -6 and -9 fatty acids from chia and flaxseed oils, and shea butter, sold as barrier repair. Three parts to that: the squalane, the omega oil blend, and the fragrance-free formulation. The honest headline of this page is that you can get two of those three back easily and the third not at all - nothing in our registry reproduces the chia-and-flaxseed omega blend, and we are not going to nominate a cream that merely contains some plant oils and call it equivalent.

What you can get back, and what you gain in exchange. The RESIST Barrier Repair Advanced cream from the same brand is fragrance-free, puts squalane 6th of 35 - ahead of its shea butter and ahead of all five of its ceramides - and carries ceramides NP, AP, AS, NS and EOP plus cholesterol, sodium hyaluronate, urea and sodium PCA. Read those two lists side by side and the swap is specific: you lose an omega-rich plant-oil blend and you gain the two lipid families a disrupted barrier is characteristically short of. If you bought the original for barrier repair rather than for the omegas specifically, that is an upgrade rather than a substitution.

One note on price before the ranking. Every number on this page is pulled live from the retailer and stamped with the date it was pulled; there are no prices written into this copy, only the ordering, so a price move changes the table rather than making these paragraphs wrong. What we can say about the shape of it is that the replacement from the same brand sits in roughly the same part of the market the original did, and that the cheapest thing on this page costs less than a quarter of any cream here.

How we picked: we don't run a lab and we don't claim to. We read every ingredient list, compiled the published specs, and computed the cost per ounce below. See our full method.

Quick picks

Our ranked shortlist. Tap a row for the full review, or the price to buy.

#ProductBest forScorePrice
1
Paula's Choice RESIST Barrier Repair Advanced Moisturizer
Paula's Choice RESIST Barrier Repair Advanced Moisturizer
Squalane 6th of 35 inside a genuine five-ceramide-plus-cholesterol barrier formula, with no fragrance on the list.
Best squalane moisturizer8.1
2
The Outset Nourishing Squalane Daily Moisturizer
The Outset Nourishing Squalane Daily Moisturizer
A genuinely gentle, fragrance-free daily cream with squalane 7th on a 45-ingredient list — pleasant to use, and priced well above what the squalane in it is worth.
Best fragrance-free squalane cream7.3
3
Kiehl's Ultra Facial Cream
Kiehl's Ultra Facial Cream
The famous one, and on the ingredient list it mostly earns it — squalane 4th of 35 at a declared 4.5%, no fragrance on the list, and a National Eczema Association Seal. The glacier and ceramide stories on the jar sit below the preservative.
A light everyday cream with squalane high on the list7.7
4
The Ordinary 100% Plant-Derived Squalane
The Ordinary 100% Plant-Derived Squalane
A single-ingredient, plant-derived squalane in a full 30 ml bottle at a low price, stocked almost everywhere — the default pick for most people.
Best overall value9.2
Paula's Choice RESIST Barrier Repair Advanced Moisturizer
#1 · Best squalane moisturizer

Paula's Choice RESIST Barrier Repair Advanced Moisturizer

8.1

Squalane 6th of 35 inside a genuine five-ceramide-plus-cholesterol barrier formula, with no fragrance on the list.

Purity
Squalane 6th of 35 ingredients
Source
Squalane + a five-ceramide and cholesterol complex
Size
1.7 fl oz (50 ml)
Cost / oz
$18.53/oz
Best for
Best squalane moisturizer

What we like

  • Squalane 6th of 35 — ahead of the shea butter and all five ceramides
  • Five ceramides (NP, AP, AS, NS, EOP) plus cholesterol, which is what barrier repair actually looks like
  • Fragrance-free and essential-oil-free on the published INCI
  • Sodium hyaluronate, urea and sodium PCA add humectants behind the emollients

Keep in mind

  • A 1.7 fl oz jar at a premium price, so the cost per ounce is high for a daily cream
  • Squalane is one of a dozen actives here — it is not the point of the formula the way it is in a plain oil
  • The brand's 100-hour hydration and 30-minute barrier claims are its own clinical testing, not independent
  • Cushioned enough that oily skin will likely prefer a plain squalane oil

Skip it if your skin is oily, or if you want single-ingredient squalane — a 100% squalane oil costs a fraction per ounce and is the same molecule.

The Outset Nourishing Squalane Daily Moisturizer
#2 · Best fragrance-free splurge

The Outset Nourishing Squalane Daily Moisturizer

7.3

A genuinely gentle, fragrance-free daily cream with squalane 7th on a 45-ingredient list — pleasant to use, and priced well above what the squalane in it is worth.

Purity
Squalane-containing daily cream
Source
Olive-derived squalane (stated by the brand)
Size
1.7 fl oz (50 ml)
Cost / oz
$31.06/oz
Best for
Best fragrance-free squalane cream

What we like

  • Fragrance-free and essential-oil-free — nothing on the list added purely to make it smell nice
  • Squalane sits 7th of 45, higher than most creams that put the word on the front
  • Olive-derived squalane, stated openly, alongside a plant-derived hyaluronic-acid alternative
  • Vegan, cruelty-free, and the brand sells a refill pouch for the full-size jar on its own site

Keep in mind

  • Priced as a luxury cream — a plain 100% squalane oil costs a small fraction of the jar's list price
  • Squalane is one of about a dozen oils here, not the point of the formula
  • Coconut oil sits 10th, which some acne-prone skin does not get on with
  • 45 ingredients including a long tail of botanical extracts — more to react to than a plain oil

Skip it if you are buying it for the squalane. A 100% squalane oil gives you far more of the ingredient for a fraction of the price — this is a well-built sensitive-skin moisturizer first and a squalane product second.

Kiehl's Ultra Facial Cream
#3 · Most squalane-forward face cream

Kiehl's Ultra Facial Cream

7.7

The famous one, and on the ingredient list it mostly earns it — squalane 4th of 35 at a declared 4.5%, no fragrance on the list, and a National Eczema Association Seal. The glacier and ceramide stories on the jar sit below the preservative.

Purity
Squalane 4th of 35 — declared 4.5%
Source
Plant-derived (Kiehl's names olives and sugarcane)
Size
1.7 fl oz (50 ml)
Cost / oz
$16.06/oz
Best for
A light everyday cream with squalane high on the list

What we like

  • Squalane 4th of 35 at a declared 4.5% — the highest position in any face cream we cover
  • States its squalane percentage outright, so you don't have to infer it from list position
  • No fragrance, parfum or essential oil on the published list; National Eczema Association Seal of Acceptance
  • Sold by Kiehl's own Amazon storefront, which also lists a larger size that costs less per ounce

Keep in mind

  • Dimethicone sits 3rd, so there is at least as much silicone as squalane in the jar
  • The glacial glycoprotein and pro-ceramide on the label sit 29th and 31st, after the preservative
  • Myristyl myristate plus seven plant oils make it a patch-test product for acne-prone skin
  • SkinSAFE rates it 91 and withholds its fragrance-free badge without naming the ingredient it flagged
  • The 72-hour hydration and 1-hour barrier claims come from the brand's own instrumental studies

Skip it if your skin breaks out easily, if you want a genuinely ceramide-rich barrier cream, or if you only want squalane — a 100% squalane oil gives you far more of it per dollar.

Buy Kiehl's Ultra Facial Cream — $27.30 · View on Amazon

$39.0030% off

Price as of November 21, 2026. Prices set by Amazon and change.

#ad · How we make money

Read the full review
The Ordinary 100% Plant-Derived Squalane
#4 · Best overall value

The Ordinary 100% Plant-Derived Squalane

9.2

A single-ingredient, plant-derived squalane in a full 30 ml bottle at a low price, stocked almost everywhere — the default pick for most people.

Purity
100% squalane
Source
Plant-derived (sugarcane)
Size
1 fl oz (30 ml)
Cost / oz
$10.40/oz
Best for
Best overall value

What we like

  • 100% squalane, no fillers or fragrance
  • One of the lowest entry prices of any name-brand squalane
  • Sugarcane-derived and vegan
  • Widely stocked, easy to repurchase

Keep in mind

  • Small 30 ml bottle
  • Simple dropper rather than an airless pump

Skip it only if you want a large-format bottle or airless packaging for oxidative stability.

Cost per ounce, compared

Computed from the current Amazon price and the listed size. Prices as of November 21, 2026 and set by Amazon.

ProductSizePriceCost / ozSource
Paula's Choice RESIST Barrier Repair Advanced Moisturizer1.7 fl oz (50 ml)$31.50$18.53/ozSqualane + a five-ceramide and cholesterol complex
The Outset Nourishing Squalane Daily Moisturizer1.7 fl oz (50 ml)$52.80$31.06/ozOlive-derived squalane (stated by the brand)
Kiehl's Ultra Facial Cream1.7 fl oz (50 ml)$27.30$16.06/ozPlant-derived (Kiehl's names olives and sugarcane)
The Ordinary 100% Plant-Derived Squalane1 fl oz (30 ml)$10.40$10.40/ozPlant-derived (sugarcane)

Why the same brand's barrier cream is the answer. If what you valued was the combination - a fragrance-free formula, lipids high on the list, and a brand whose formulations publish their reasoning - the RESIST Barrier Repair Advanced is the nearest thing in existence to the product you lost, from the people who made it. It is cushioned, it layers under sunscreen, and squalane is genuinely high in it rather than decorative. The honest cons are the ones on its card: a 1.7 fl oz jar at a premium price gives it a high cost per ounce; squalane is one of a dozen actives here rather than the point of the formula; the brand's 100-hour hydration and 30-minute barrier figures come from its own clinical testing, not independent work; and it is rich enough that oily skin will probably prefer a plain oil.

The second pick is for anyone whose first requirement was the fragrance-free part. The Outset Nourishing Squalane Daily Moisturizer puts squalane 7th of 45 and carries no fragrance, parfum or essential oil anywhere on its published list - and it is the only other fragrance-free squalane face cream in our registry, which is the reason it is here. It is the most expensive cream on this page by a clear margin, which is the main argument against it, and three other things are worth knowing: squalane is one of about a dozen oils in it rather than the base, coconut oil sits 10th which some acne-prone skin does not get on with, and a 45-ingredient list with a long botanical tail gives you more to react to than the original had.

The third pick is the lighter, cheaper everyday option, and the one to choose if the Omega+ Complex was always slightly too rich for you - which was a common complaint about it. Kiehl's Ultra Facial Cream declares 4.5% squalane at 4th of 35, the highest declared percentage in any face cream we cover, and it is light and fast on the skin. The caveats are real: dimethicone sits 3rd, so there is at least as much silicone as squalane in it; the glacial glycoprotein and pro-ceramide sit 29th and 31st, after the preservative; myristyl myristate plus seven plant oils make it a patch-test product if you are acne-prone; and while no fragrance appears on its list, SkinSAFE rates it 91 and withholds its fragrance-free badge without saying what it flagged.

Why a bottle of plain squalane is on a page about replacing a cream. Because one of the three things the original did - put emollient lipids between your skin cells and slow the water leaving - is exactly what a bottle of 100% squalane does, for a fraction of the money, with one ingredient and nothing to react to. It will not give you the humectants, the ceramides or the omega oils. What it will do, used on skin that is still damp, is make a surprising amount of difference for the price of a sandwich, which is why it is the budget pick on almost every page here. If your skin was doing fine on the Omega+ Complex and you are not sure whether you need a cream at all, buy this first and find out before you spend four times as much.

And the gap, restated so nobody buys the wrong thing. If you specifically want the omega-3 and omega-6 plant-oil blend - the chia and flaxseed part - no product in our registry gives it to you, and the closest in spirit is the Youth To The People Superberry Dream Oil, which is a squalane-and-omega-oil blend rather than a cream and is lightly scented, so it fails the fragrance-free test the original passed. The other honest route is to keep whichever cream above suits you and add a separate omega oil over the top at night. Our squalane oil vs moisturizer comparison is the right next read if you are deciding between a cream and an oil, and the original's full review is still up with the discontinuation on it.

Frequently asked questions

What is the best alternative to Paula's Choice Omega+ Complex Moisturizer?

Paula's Choice RESIST Barrier Repair Advanced Moisturizer, from the same brand. It is fragrance-free like the original, squalane sits 6th of 35 ahead of the shea butter and all five ceramides, and it adds ceramides plus cholesterol - the two lipid families a disrupted barrier tends to be short of. What it does not give you is the chia and flaxseed omega blend.

Is the Omega+ Complex Moisturizer discontinued?

Yes. Paula's Choice stopped making it, and we verified the Amazon listing as "Currently unavailable" on 6 September 2026 and again on 29 September 2026. It is excluded from our price layer for that reason, so you will not find a live price or a buy link for it anywhere on this site - only a review that says what it was.

Is there a dupe for the Omega+ Complex Moisturizer?

Not a like-for-like one, and we would rather say so. You can replace the fragrance-free barrier-cream part easily, with the Paula's Choice RESIST cream or The Outset's. You cannot replace the chia-and-flaxseed omega oil blend from anything in our registry. If the omegas were the reason you bought it, a separate omega-rich oil layered over a simpler cream is the honest workaround.

What did the Omega+ Complex Moisturizer actually contain?

It was a fragrance-free cream built around squalane, omega-3, -6 and -9 fatty acids from chia and flaxseed oils, and shea butter, positioned for barrier repair. Three features mattered to most people who bought it: the lipids, the omega oils, and the absence of fragrance. Two of those three are easy to replace; the omega blend is not.

Is the replacement from Paula's Choice as good?

On barrier repair, arguably better - it carries five ceramides and cholesterol, which the original did not, with squalane ahead of all of them. On the omega oils, no, because it does not have them. Whether that is an upgrade or a loss depends entirely on which half of the original formula you were buying it for.

Is there a cheaper alternative to the Omega+ Complex?

A bottle of 100% squalane, at a fraction of any cream on this page. It replaces the emollient half of what the original did - lipids between the skin cells, slower water loss - with one ingredient and nothing to react to. It does not replace the humectants, ceramides or omega oils, so it is the right answer for skin that was doing fine and the wrong one for a struggling barrier.

Are all of these alternatives fragrance-free?

The Paula's Choice and The Outset creams carry no fragrance, parfum or essential oil on their published lists, and neither does a bottle of pure squalane. The Kiehl's cream has none on its list either, but SkinSAFE rates it 91 and withholds its fragrance-free badge without naming what it flagged - so if fragrance is a hard constraint, start with our [fragrance-free picks](/best-fragrance-free-squalane).

Which replacement is best for oily skin?

None of the creams, probably. The Paula's Choice is cushioned, The Outset lists coconut oil 10th, and the Kiehl's carries myristyl myristate plus seven plant oils - all three are patch-test products if you break out easily. Oily skin that liked the original's lightness is usually better served by a plain squalane oil, and our [best squalane oil for oily skin](/best-squalane-oil-for-oily-skin) page covers that case properly.

Sources

Replacing a cream with an oil instead?

Squalane oil vs moisturizer sets out what a cream adds that an oil cannot, and when a plain oil is genuinely enough.

Read the comparison